I hope that my response will prove to be of some assistance to you.
The father in question displays a profound concern for his daughter, yet his communication style is characterized by frequent shouting. The daughter, however, perceives this behavior as irritating and believes that her father's tone is mocking. Consequently, each instance of shouting elicits annoyance, leading to the belief that her father is unresponsive and uncooperative. This cyclical pattern perpetuates a negative perception of her father's actions.
What, then, is the appropriate course of action?
It is this author's recommendation that:
It would be beneficial to attempt to comprehend the underlying motives behind your father's actions, recognize the affection and care he has for you, and endeavor to accept his behavior. This approach may help to mitigate your annoyance.
It is understandable that you expect your father to stop calling you, to let you lie down freely, and to let you drink water whenever you want. However, it is important to recognize that the real father will always keep calling you and reminding you to do this and that. This discrepancy between your expectations and the reality of the situation can lead to conflict between the father you expect and the real father.
It is also important to acknowledge that it is challenging to change the real father. As you mentioned, communicating with him will not necessarily result in him listening to you. He will likely continue to engage in these behaviors because, for a person who is not willing to change, it is difficult for others to facilitate that change.
In "A Change of Heart," the author posits that there are three categories of affairs: our own, other people's, and the affairs of heaven. The source of distress for many individuals is their preoccupation with the affairs of others and the affairs of heaven, which they perceive as beyond their control. Consequently, they tend to neglect their own affairs. The actions and statements of one's father, therefore, become a matter of personal concern. The influence of his upbringing shapes his behavior, and he is comfortable with this pattern. In fact, he may resist change.
Therefore, when he calls you repeatedly, he is actually expressing concern, and behind the concern is care. He is worried that you are not consuming sufficient water and are prone to illness, that you are not getting sufficient exercise and are prone to physical discomfort. It is simply that his method of expressing it is not the one you expect; however, that is simply the way he is. If you do not accept him in this manner, you will continue to be troubled by his reappearance of such behavior, but he will still appear, because he truly is just the way he is. This is a stable pattern.
Furthermore, when one attempts to accept their father's behavior, it is no longer a source of distress. One comes to accept that he is simply the way he is and desires for him to be different. This results in a sense of ease and a shift in expectations. Instead of experiencing conflict, one develops a more reasonable outlook on their father and is better able to interact with him in a harmonious manner.
2. Are you conscious of the manner in which you interact with your father and the vocabulary you employ? Do you engage in criticism and accusation? To communicate effectively, it is essential to do so on the basis of respect, acceptance, and understanding of the other person, expressing one's feelings and needs, as well as specific requests of him.
You indicate that when you communicate with him, he does not listen to what you say, does not respond positively, and always speaks to you with a mocking expression, which makes you feel very powerless. This is an illustrative example of the necessity for good communication to adhere to two fundamental principles: firstly, the establishment of a conducive communication atmosphere, and secondly, the absence of any criticism or accusation.
If we express our thoughts when our father is in the midst of an emotional state, it will be challenging for him to engage in a constructive dialogue. If we initiate the interaction by placing blame on him, he will likely activate his defense mechanism and respond in a defensive or aggressive manner, which will impede the ability to effectively communicate our concerns.
It is therefore essential that the expression be made in an atmosphere conducive to effective communication. One such occasion might be during a meal together, when both parties are relaxed. When expressing oneself, it is important to avoid the use of criticism and accusation, and instead present the objective facts. For example, one might say, "Dad, today you told me to drink water and get up and walk around, which I found somewhat annoying and uncomfortable. I hope you will respect my free time and my space, and also believe that I can take care of myself. In the future, I would appreciate it if you would refrain from telling me to drink water and get up and walk around. When you have more important needs, you can call me again, okay?"
It is also possible to consider the perspective of the father. He may express concern about the child's wellbeing, citing fears of illness or an inability to provide adequate care. Such communication can facilitate a deeper understanding of each other's needs and facilitate growth through conflict. By focusing on the underlying issues, it is possible to avoid prolonged distress caused by superficial disagreements.
It is my sincere hope that this information will prove beneficial. I encourage you to prioritize your well-being during this period of social distancing.
Wishing you the best.
Comments
I understand how you feel, it's tough being in such a situation. Maybe you could try setting up a schedule for yourself that includes water breaks and movement, then show him you're taking care of yourself.
It seems like your dad might be expressing his concern in a way that doesn't quite land right with you. Have you considered writing him a note or a letter to explain how you feel when he shouts?
Sometimes older generations have different ways of showing care. It might help if you can find a moment when he's calm to talk about how his shouting affects you, and ask if you two can find a middle ground.
Your father might not realize how his actions are affecting you. Perhaps you could ask a relative or even a friend to help mediate a conversation between the two of you, someone who understands both perspectives.
It sounds like there's a communication barrier here. You could suggest using a whiteboard or a chat app where you can type messages to each other, which might lead to a more thoughtful exchange.