My name is Annie.
From your description, it's clear that your younger brother's actions were dangerous. You gave him a kind reminder as an older brother, but he didn't accept it. Instead, he made your mother think it was your problem. Give the aggrieved questioner a hug.
Your mother's reaction seems disproportionate. Do you also feel that she should blame your brother, but instead blames you for trying to reason with her? If you and your brother both made a mistake today, for example, if you two were fighting or playing around, would your mother still only blame you?
Your mother will scold you and your brother.
If you both made a mistake and your mother only scolds you, it's obvious she's partial. But if she punishes both of you, will the questioner still think she's unfair?
In all three incidents you described, your younger brother was in the wrong, and yet you were the only one being blamed. I don't know the situation at the time or what happened before, but it seems clear that your mother is biased. Is there any other possibility?
"My mom blamed me for saying that I should play with my brother to attract attention instead of saying that he was wrong."
I don't know if the mother was driving at this time. It's possible that the father was driving and the mother was sitting in the passenger seat.
If mom says she is driving at this time, the driver's attention must be focused on the road conditions. They will not be able to pay attention to what is going on between you. Therefore, they will tell the questioner to play with his brother. They do not think the younger brother is wrong, but they hope that under your leadership, they can attract the younger brother's attention to avoid danger.
My brother was playing with the end of the charger cable while soaking his feet. It was plugged in, so I told him not to play with it because he might drop it in the water and get electrocuted. He didn't listen, so I threatened to tell on him if he dropped it. Then my mom turned around and said I was threatening my brother on purpose.
The questioner stated that her mother was right next to her brother when the incident occurred. It was similar to the previous time her brother stuck his hand out of the car window. Her mother did not explicitly state whether her brother was wrong or right. However, this time, the questioner scared her brother, which prompted her mother to focus on the incident and question you.
Then the questioner stated, "When my brother was eating, he poked the watermelon next to him with his hand. I told him off, but my mother instead said that I always see the faults in others."
I don't know why my mother thinks this way, but I know the questioner doesn't agree with her. Has the questioner asked his mother why she always thinks he sees his brother's shortcomings?
Or did you just bear with it?
To prevent the original poster from being troubled by similar matters in the future, I am providing the following suggestions for reference:
First, state your true thoughts and feelings directly.
It's possible that the questioner hasn't expressed your true thoughts about these matters to your mother. It's likely that your mother thinks the questioner is more sensible than your younger brother, so she has higher expectations and demands of you. However, if the questioner doesn't say what's on his mind, her mother may continue to think that she's done nothing wrong and nothing will change.
The questioner can clearly express your thoughts in a calm manner at the moment the incident occurs. For example, when saying "My mother instead blamed me for drawing attention to myself by playing with my brother instead of telling him he was wrong," you can say
"I saw my brother's head and hands sticking out of the window, and I knew it was dangerous. I told him to put his head and hands back inside, but he didn't. Instead of scolding him, my mother asked me to play with him, which made me feel a bit aggrieved."
Tell the truth. Don't get angry. When the questioner says this, her mother will realize there's a problem with her approach and adjust her attitude towards handling future incidents.
Second, give advice and let others choose for themselves.
From the three questions you have asked, it is clear that your younger brother is not listening to you and is even fighting against you.
The questioner can also use the above method of communicating with his mother to express his feelings to his younger brother. It is fine to give simple and concise advice. The questioner should allow his younger brother the freedom to choose whether or not to do what he wants, because he also needs to learn to take responsibility for his risky behavior.
If your mother is difficult to communicate with, you can seek the assistance of your father.
If the questioner still hasn't changed their mind after communicating your thoughts to your mother, you should involve your father in the discussion. When the four of you are together, the opinions of the non-parties can reduce the chance of biased opinions.
The questioner will communicate smoothly, and your wishes will be fulfilled.
You've got this! Yixinli and I are behind you all the way.
Comments
This situation sounds really frustrating. It's tough when you're trying to look out for your brother and keep him safe, but it feels like your efforts aren't appreciated or understood by your family. I can see why you're upset.
It's important to have a conversation with your mom about safety concerns. Maybe explaining the dangers of sticking limbs out of a car window or playing with electrical cords could help her understand why these actions are not just about attention but serious safety issues. Communication is key here.
I totally get how annoying this must be for you. Your intentions seem good, but they clash with what your mom expects from you. Perhaps finding a way to gently guide your brother towards safer behaviors without coming off as scolding might work better in getting everyone on the same page.
Feeling like you're constantly at odds with your family over safety issues must be exhausting. It might help to bring up these concerns calmly with your parents, maybe even show them some resources or articles that explain the risks involved. Sometimes seeing evidence can change someone's mind more effectively than just telling them.