light mode dark mode

How to determine whether a counseling relationship is good or bad?

depression high school hospital visit counseling relationship suitability assessment
readership6670 favorite40 forward27
How to determine whether a counseling relationship is good or bad? By Anonymous | Published on December 18, 2024

I was depressed in my senior year of high school, but I didn't know it. It wasn't until I was crying and complaining about life and had no passion or motivation that my parents took me to the hospital and said, "I'm going to the hospital to expose you." I didn't have any expectations of the doctor, because at that time I had long since given up on expecting anything.

But I didn't realize that the half hour I spent talking to the doctor gave me far more hope than the 12 yuan consultation fee.

At the end of our third session, he assessed that I could stop consulting with him. At the end of the session, he insisted on having a conversation with my parents. At first, my mother didn't want to, but he insisted. After talking for half an hour, he came out and my mother became a lot more understanding...

I believe this was a good counseling relationship, but there are probably many people, like me at the beginning, who are ignorant and think that just receiving counseling and talking about it will solve the problem. They may not know how to judge whether a counseling relationship is good or not, and how to judge whether a counselor is suitable for them. Can you teachers give some advice?

Marguerite Marguerite A total of 2988 people have been helped

Good day, question asker. I am Enoch, the designated answer provider.

The client elected to pursue counseling with the assistance of his parents due to depressive symptoms he was experiencing during his senior year of high school. After undergoing counseling, the client felt that the investment was worthwhile. However, he lacked the ability to assess the quality of the counseling relationship and his suitability for such a relationship.

In fact, the questioner has gained a great deal from this relationship. However, over time, due to the harm done to him by his family, he has become suspicious of people and relationships in general. This has led him to question whether the positive counseling relationship is genuinely beneficial.

The questioner views counseling as an act of vulnerability, akin to "going to the hospital to expose myself," rather than a means of healing. This perception leads to the questioner's belief that his parents do not truly believe in his depression and are merely attempting to expose his disguise with ill intent. Consequently, the questioner resists counseling. However, during the counseling process, the questioner observed the counselor's friendliness and experienced a sense of healing. Despite this positive experience, the questioner's doubts about the counselor and the relationship persisted, mirroring his mother's initial skepticism. This led to the questioner questioning the authenticity of the counselor and the relationship.

This is a projection of one's feelings for one's parents onto the counselor in the counseling relationship. Even if the other person is very nice, one still feels that the other person is a kind of disguise, so one can create resistance to the counselor and the counseling relationship. Resistance can destroy the counseling relationship and is not conducive to counseling. Therefore, the questioner should eliminate their suspicious mentality and bravely accept the counselor in order to bring better help to themselves.

It is my hope that the questioner will be able to overcome their doubts, demonstrate active cooperation, and facilitate their own healing process.

Helpful to meHelpful to me 504
disapprovedisapprove0
Emma Woods Emma Woods A total of 1136 people have been helped

Hello!

Many people have the wrong idea about psychological counseling. I used to think that if you have an unsolvable problem, a counselor can help. If you have such hopes, I'm afraid you will be disappointed.

Psychological counseling is a journey where the counselor and client work together to understand themselves better. The counselor listens to the client and helps them with techniques when needed. The client also needs to make personal efforts.

The counseling relationship is a two-way street.

Good counseling is when the client has a positive experience and gets what they need.

A good counseling relationship:

1. You will feel good.

You will feel comfortable and at ease. You will feel like you have gained something and gained some deep insights. You can open up and tell the counselor whatever you want to say. You will feel very comfortable and secure.

2. Better self-esteem

A good counselor helps you see things more positively.

A good counseling relationship is comfortable, warm, and safe. You trust the person in front of you and feel understood.

Best wishes!

Helpful to meHelpful to me 443
disapprovedisapprove0

Comments

avatar
Selene Thomas The pursuit of knowledge in different fields is like a pilgrimage, with each step adding to one's erudition.

I can totally relate to your experience. It's amazing how a single conversation can turn things around when you're at your lowest. Sometimes we need that external perspective to help us see the light again.

avatar
Carina Love Truth crushed to earth shall rise again.

It sounds like you went through a really tough time, and I'm glad you found support. The doctor seemed to have made a real difference by not only helping you but also involving your parents in the process. That's so important for recovery.

avatar
Eliza Bloom A broad - based knowledge is the foundation of a truly learned individual.

Your story resonates with me because it shows the power of professional help. Even though you felt hopeless, that one session sparked something within you. It's proof that sometimes we just need someone to listen and guide us in the right direction.

avatar
Padraig Davis Life is a dream that we are living through.

What you described is a perfect example of why therapy works. It's not just about talking; it's about finding solutions and getting the support system involved. Your counselor did a great job in bridging the gap between you and your family.

avatar
Jayson Davis Life is a chain reaction of choices and consequences.

It's incredible how much impact a good therapist can have. They don't just offer advice but also change the way those around you understand what you're going through. It's clear that this was a turning point for you.

More from Soul Share Cove

This feature is under maintenance and update.
Close