Hello, question asker! I'm so honored to answer your question.
I totally get it. The problems you described have the following points:
1. Your family has two little ones, and your sweet mother was originally going to take care of them. Unfortunately, she hurt her hand, so she's now hoping your father's and mother's side can lend a hand.
2. Your mother-in-law is doing a great job of raising two children for your younger brother, but having four children is probably a lot to handle. She suggested that your father-in-law help out, but he said no because there are two dogs at their home. This makes you feel a little hurt, but you know your father-in-law has good reasons for saying no.
3. Your sister-in-law made a good point about your mother babysitting, but she didn't say that she would let your mother help. Your mother-in-law also said you didn't go home for the New Year, but you actually did go home. It's understandable that you feel a bit aggrieved.
4. You've been holding it all in for so long, and you finally couldn't hold back anymore. You went looking for a fight and expected an apology, but things got even worse. I know it must have been really tough for you.
It's totally understandable to have doubts about this matter. Is the conflict between the mother-in-law and daughter-in-law due to the involvement of your sister-in-law, or is it because you are narrow-minded and petty?
I feel like the main thing missing here is non-violent communication. It's so important to be able to talk to each other in a way that's respectful and kind. I think you should try to communicate with your husband, your mother-in-law, and your sister-in-law in a way that's more open and understanding.
I can see why you'd want to let your mother take care of the kids. I'm sure she'd be happy to help out! But I just wanted to flag that some mothers-in-law might feel deprived of their right to take care of their grandchildren. It's worth chatting with your mother-in-law in advance to make sure she's OK with this. I'm sure she'd understand if she couldn't come, but it's good to check in!
I bet your sister-in-law said something similar for the same reason.
I really think that if you explain to your sister-in-law why you didn't let your mother-in-law bring the baby and tell her about your concerns and worries, she'll understand you better and won't misunderstand you.
I can see why you went to your mother's house to argue. It's a tricky situation! You could have avoided it by not going yourself, telling your husband the reason for the argument, and asking her to coordinate with your mother and sister. Stay calm, and I'm sure you'll get through this together.
I really hope these ideas help you understand things better, OP!


Comments
I can see why you're feeling so upset and hurt by the whole situation. It's frustrating when family dynamics don't work out as expected, especially when it comes to caring for children. I would have felt the same way if my efforts and sacrifices were overlooked like that.
It sounds like there's a lot of miscommunication going on. Maybe we should try to talk things through with your motherinlaw and sisterinlaw calmly. Sometimes people say things without thinking, and they might not realize how their words affect others.
The priority should always be the wellbeing of the children, and it seems like everyone is trying to do what they think is best. However, it's also important that your feelings and contributions are acknowledged. Perhaps setting up a family meeting could help clear the air and find a solution that works for everyone.
Feeling undervalued and unappreciated is really tough, especially in a family setting. It's understandable that you'd feel angry when your own mother has to step in because of the situation with your motherinlaw. You deserve to have your needs and concerns heard and addressed.
I'm sorry you've been put in such a difficult position. It's hard when you're trying to balance everything and still face criticism. Maybe it's time to set some boundaries and express clearly what you need from your family. It's okay to ask for support and to stand up for yourself when necessary.