Hello, question asker.
From your description, it's clear you care a lot about whether you can catch the other person's drift well. If your response doesn't have the effect you want, you feel uncomfortable and your heart feels blocked. And if you don't give a response to someone's words in time, you also feel uncomfortable and suffocated.
You will undoubtedly recognize the importance of being able to talk. I believe that these are the fundamental criteria for being able to talk in your heart:
1. Don't let yourself down. Always express the emotions you want to convey.
2. You must ensure that others understand you and that your meaning is clear.
3. You must not let the other person be dissatisfied, and you must not make others angry with you.
The above three points are the most important principles you should adhere to. They are your inner beliefs, and if you fail to follow them, you will feel uncomfortable and will always want to make up for this mistake.
You are usually more cautious with your words to adhere to the requirements you have set for yourself. You are especially cautious around unfamiliar people. You may swallow the words you have on the tip of your tongue and not say them to avoid angering the other person. However, this goes against another principle of yours: "If you have something to say, say it; if you have an emotion you want to express, don't hold back." You will feel pain, depression, resentment, and self-blame for this.
I understand how you feel. In fact, if we can all do a good job of the above "talking" standards, it would be best. We all have such high expectations of ourselves, but when we can't achieve them, we give up on the pursuit of perfection. Sometimes it's enough just to implement the first standard, as long as you don't compromise yourself.
However, you demand more of yourself when it comes to communication or interpersonal relationships. You may also know that it is difficult to achieve everything in some situations, and you always have to make trade-offs, but you will feel very uncomfortable after making a trade-off.
This is your problem.
Think back and ask yourself what it is that makes you unable to let go of your obsession with "knowing how to talk." Is it more important not to compromise yourself or not to make others hate you?
You can become an expert in the art of conversation through active training. However, you will inevitably encounter situations like today, so you must self-regulate this kind of emotion or mentality.
You have likely experienced something impressive before, which has given you similar somatic feelings and emotions. This has led to a psychological defense mechanism of fear after similar or attributed events. You have a strong emphasis on a certain aspect as a result.
Ask yourself what caused you to react this way to a similar event in the past. Once you've identified the reason, tell yourself: 1. You are now different from the past. 2. The current situation is different from past experiences. What happened before is in the past, and there's no reason to be afraid.
3. You can't predict the future, but you can change your past. Enemies can become friends. Mistakes can be redeemed.
I am confident this will help. Best wishes.


Comments
I totally get what you're going through. It's tough when you sense a miscommunication but don't know how to address it. Maybe next time you could just laugh it off and say, That's not really my style, is it?
Sometimes people hint at things awkwardly. If it happens again, you might gently ask, Are you thinking about something specific? It can clear up the confusion without making it too heavy.
It sounds like you're feeling quite sensitive around her. Maybe take a step back and think about whether you want to be more open with this person or keep your distance. Trust your instincts on that.
When someone suggests something uncomfortable, like cheating, responding with humor can ease the tension. You could say, Wow, I didn't even consider that! Not my thing at all. It deflects while setting boundaries.
Feeling stuck after someone says something hurtful is so frustrating. Next time, if you feel ready, you could respond right away with, That comment caught me off guard. It helps to voice your feelings even if it's not perfect.