Good day. I extend my sincerest regards to you in the form of a 360-degree hug.
In her family of origin, she exhibited a peaceful and content demeanor. However, in my family, she displayed moodiness and unpredictability. It can be stated that my mother exhibited two distinct personas in different environments and with different individuals.
From your inquiries, it is evident that your mother exhibits varying behaviors with different individuals.
Regarding your mother's relationship with her family of origin, it is my understanding that her temperament was notably absent. Alternatively, I would characterize her demeanor as emotionally composed.
Please describe the nature of your mother's relationships with her family of origin, including the quality and tone of their interactions. In your question, the family of origin demonstrated a relatively high level of education. Additionally, your mother did not express any negative sentiments about her family of origin.
The relationship between your mother and her neighbors was relatively amicable. If a neighbor was late getting up, your mother would say, "You're up late today."
The relationship between your mother and her in-laws was characterized by a tendency to be on the defensive, engage in heated exchanges, display hostile body language, and engage in constant criticism of your father's family. The underlying reason for this dynamic, as you have indicated, is your father's perceived irresponsibility and lack of commitment.
You have previously indicated that you do not view your mother in a positive light.
Your summary is that in your mother's psychological intimacy, there is a discrepancy between how outsiders and in-laws perceive her, and how family members and your father's relatives perceive her.
It is likely that your father was the source of the greatest level of dissatisfaction.
I believe you are aware of the reason. Your question compares your mother's interactions with different individuals, some of whom are pleasant and some of whom are disagreeable.
While your mother displays an ability to remain calm and smile in other contexts, this ability seems to disappear when she interacts with your father, you, and your family's relatives.
There is only one reason: the atmosphere of emotional peace has disappeared. To illustrate this with an example, imagine a husband who does nothing and is a hands-off boss, and a daughter who often says she is no good. It is reasonable to assume that the daughter would be grumpy too.
This is solely from the perspective of a daughter who is dissatisfied with her mother. I am unaware of how your grandparents, aunts, and uncles in your family treated your mother.
This aspect was not covered in the original text, but it seems unlikely that the relationship was particularly amicable.
You indicated that my father was the source of her greatest dissatisfaction. I am curious as to how your parents came to be married.
It was a marriage of convenience, or perhaps a forced marriage. Given that your mother's family had a higher level of education, it seems unlikely that they would have chosen to marry your father. Additionally, your mother was not very old at the time, and it is possible that she was already in love or at least had met and gotten to know your father before the marriage. However, you also mentioned that your father was the person she was least satisfied with.
Was she dissatisfied from the outset? Based on my experience, if she was dissatisfied from the outset, given her age, she could have declined the proposal.
In other words, even if there was no deep emotional foundation at the beginning, at least your mother agreed to marry your father of her own accord. However, there seems to have been a significant discrepancy between your parents' expectations and their actual compatibility. Why did your father end up being the person your mother was most dissatisfied with?
Please provide further details regarding the circumstances that transpired between these two points in time. It is likely that these events are the root cause of her erratic behavior within your family.
As a daughter, your phrasing of the question indicates that you view your mother as an outsider. You mention "her family, her family members, her family home," which is an unusual choice of words. It also suggests that you are not close to your mother and that you may have always regarded her as an outsider in your family.
It is possible that you do not consider your mother's family to be your own.
This dynamic is evident in your relationship with your father and, undoubtedly, in your interactions with your grandparents, who likely perceive your mother as an outsider. Her constant defensiveness indicates a pervasive sense of insecurity and a need to protect herself.
A person in a defensive state is not in a relaxed state by nature.
It is likely that your mother only feels warmth from those outside of her immediate family, and she returns that warmth.
If an individual has positive interactions with most people but struggles with their spouse and children, it may indicate that they have expectations of their spouse and children but are disappointed. Additionally, they may be reluctant to give up these expectations, which could contribute to emotional instability.
If she has no expectations and is disillusioned, she may even request a divorce directly.
It is therefore my assessment that the disparate states exhibited by your mother are a result of inadequate support from your family of three, or an underlying issue in her marriage to your father. The question you posed indicates the presence of a significant challenge.
A strong marriage is the foundation of a healthy family.
Given the circumstances, there is little you can do to influence your mother's behavior. It would be beneficial for your parents to seek family therapy, during which your father would need to make some adjustments.
In addition, it is evident that you hold a bias against your mother and perceive her through a distorted lens. This is an important issue that requires your attention. I recommend consulting with a psychologist to address this matter.
I am a counselor who is often Buddhist and sometimes pessimistic, occasionally positive, and motivated. I extend my best wishes to you and the world.


Comments
I can see how painful and confusing this situation must be for you. It's hard to understand why your mother seems to have such a different attitude toward family compared to outsiders. Sometimes people carry complex emotions from their past that affect their present relationships in ways they might not even realize.
It sounds like there's a lot of unspoken tension and hurt within your family. Maybe your mother's frustration stems from unmet expectations or unresolved issues with your father. It's possible she feels more comfortable and accepted with her mother's side of the family, which could explain why she behaves differently around them.
Your feelings of envy when you see your mother interact warmly with others reflect a deep desire for that kind of connection within your own family. It's natural to wish for a relationship where love and respect flow easily between family members.
It's interesting that you mention your mother never speaks negatively about her mother's relatives. Perhaps there's a history or dynamic there that makes those relationships feel safer or more positive to her. It's also possible that her father's side of the family represents a source of pain or disappointment that she's unwilling to revisit.
You're right; it does seem strange that intimacy should be so skewed towards outsiders rather than family. Ideally, home should be a place of comfort and support. I wonder if there's a way to bridge that gap and bring some of that warmth back into your family interactions.